|Year : 2017 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 1-7
Comparative analysis of depression and its associated risk factors among public and private medical schools students in Karachi, Pakistan: A multicenter study
Mubashir Zafar, S Bushra Rizvi, Laraib Sheikh, Noor-ul-Huda, Zaineb Khalid, Tahir Ghulam Abbas, Sheema Waseem, Ali Khan, Samreen Aijaz, Sahab Akram, Sidra Arshad, Umar Khalid, Bushra Shahid, Saima Ahmed, Marium Aftab, Ahsan Usman, Ramsha Aslam
Department of Community Medicine, Jinnah Sindh Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan
|Date of Web Publication||17-Jul-2017|
Department of Community Medicine, Jinnah Sindh Medical University, Karachi
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Context: It is estimated that 15.2%–43.8% of depression among medical students worldwide. Subjects and Methods: The purpose of this study was to compare the prevalence of depression and anxiety among the public and private sector. Setting and Design: This cross-sectional study was carried out among the students of private and public sector medical schools using convenient sampling validated “Becks depression scale.” Students of age group between 20 and 25 were included in the study. The dependent variable was depression, and independent variables were age, gender, religion, marital status, father's occupation, ethnicity, and the addiction history of the participants. Statistical Analysis Used: Logistic regression analysis is used to determine the association between depression and sociodemographic statistics. Results: Mean age and standard deviation of students were 23 ± 2 years. In univariate analysis, students suffered 1.8 times in public sector (odds ratio [OR]: 1.185, confidence interval [CI]: 0.537–2.614.), married students were 9.2 times (OR: 9.205, CI: 3.165–26.770), with a past depression history 14.3 times (OR: 14.397, CI: 5.928–34.961), with family history 3.6 times (OR: 3.684, CI: 1.477–9.189), with addiction history 5.4 times (OR: 5.413, CI: 1.729–16.979) and students whose fathers are businessmen were 2.9 times (OR: 2.92, CI: 1.024–5.127) more depressed. On multivariate analysis, only students with a past depression history were significantly 8.3 times more likely to suffer from depression (OR: 8.309, CI: 2.971–23.244). Conclusion: The study identifies that depression is more common in public sector students. This finding helps to develop policies for overcoming these problems which includes easy syllabus for students and providing them career counseling and guidance.
Keywords: Depression, Karachi, medical schools, public-private
|How to cite this article:|
Zafar M, Rizvi S B, Sheikh L, Nu, Khalid Z, Abbas TG, Waseem S, Khan A, Aijaz S, Akram S, Arshad S, Khalid U, Shahid B, Ahmed S, Aftab M, Usman A, Aslam R. Comparative analysis of depression and its associated risk factors among public and private medical schools students in Karachi, Pakistan: A multicenter study. Saudi J Health Sci 2017;6:1-7
|How to cite this URL:|
Zafar M, Rizvi S B, Sheikh L, Nu, Khalid Z, Abbas TG, Waseem S, Khan A, Aijaz S, Akram S, Arshad S, Khalid U, Shahid B, Ahmed S, Aftab M, Usman A, Aslam R. Comparative analysis of depression and its associated risk factors among public and private medical schools students in Karachi, Pakistan: A multicenter study. Saudi J Health Sci [serial online] 2017 [cited 2017 Dec 17];6:1-7. Available from: http://www.saudijhealthsci.org/text.asp?2017/6/1/1/210818
| Introduction|| |
Depression is a common mental disorder, characterized by sadness, loss of interest or pleasure, feelings of guilt or low self-worth, disturbed sleep or appetite, feelings of tiredness, and poor concentration. It involves the body, mood, and thoughts. These symptoms interfere with your daily life routines, the ability to work, sleep, study, eat, and enjoy life. The residence, age, marital status, educational status, the number of diagnosed chronic noncommunicable diseases (heart diseases, diabetic Mellitus, and arthritis), and alcohol drinking are associated risk factors of depression.
Depression has become inevitable with increasing time; it does not only encompass aged people but also undergraduate students, housewives, employees, etc., in its circle. Many researches have been carried out as a study of depression among medical students and several studies have suggested a higher prevalence of depression among medical students than the general population. According to different studies, stress among medical students has been ranging from 12% to 73%.,
Other researchers suggest that  the prevalence of depression among medical students in public universities has been estimated to be 15.2% in the USA, 21.7% in Malaysia, 24% in the UK, 29.1% in India, and 43.8% in Pakistan. The prevalence of depression among private medical students, however, has been estimated to be 19% in the USA, 49.1% in India, and 60% in Pakistan.
According to different studies, 335 students were assessed for depressive symptoms, and nearly half of them were found to be depressed with 2% having severe depression., Depression was found to be present in 60% and 70% in two different studies of medical and private colleges. The studies also show that there was no difference of gender with regards to the development of depression symptoms.,
Medical schools and colleges are recognized as a stressful environment that often exerts a negative effect on the academic performance, physical health, and psychological well-being of the students. A study showed that students affected with these symptoms have a prevalence of 68% of 400 medical students. Retrieving knowledge about the presence of these conditions is important in itself and if found, would need attention., Studies have indicated that the medical students experience the highest degree of pressure from studies. A gender difference regarding stress levels has also been reported, where women reported higher levels of stress than men (crude odds ratio among male:female 7:9).,
There was no previous study conducted in Karachi, Pakistan as a comparison between medical students of public and private colleges on an objective of the prevalence of depression. It is a unique multicenter study, providing variations of participants that covers different aspects and highlights diversities of concerned regions. This was done using a self-administered depression questionnaire so that this research proves to be helpful to consider the factors responsible for occurrence and symptoms of depression which leads to an individuals' isolation, self-harm, and even suicide attempts. The motive is to benefit the policy makers and stakeholders to overcome the knowledge gap and develop new interventions for its prevention and take steps on how to eradicate these factors for the betterment of an individual.
| Subjects and Methods|| |
The scale used in this study is “Beck's depression scale.” Participants with a cut-off of 20 and above were considered depressed.
This cross-sectional study was carried out among undergraduates of private and public sector medical schools in Karachi.
Four medical schools were selected. Two for each public and private medical school.
The study instrument used was a validated questionnaire comprising two sections. Part one was related to sociodemographic characteristics, and part two was related to depression which was assessed by a 21 items questionnaire. It was prepared in English language.
The scale that was used to assess depression level is Beck's Depression Scale. A self-administered questionnaire was utilized. The questionnaire includes Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)-II test which is 21 items self-report, having a four point scale ranging, which ranges from 0 (symptoms not present) to 3 (extreme symptoms). The test requires approximately 5–10 min to finish. Participants with a cut-off of 20 and above were considered depressed. Total score of 20–30 points toward mild mood disturbance, 30–40 indicates moderate clinical depression, and 4060 displays severe depression. The BDI test is broadly recognized and has been verified for concurrent, construct, and content validity. This scale was formerly designed by Aaron T. Beck. In 1961, collating patient's illustration of their symptoms depressed mood, hopelessness, lack of energy, persistent sadness, poor self-esteem, guilt, perception of failure, self-discontent crying irritability, fatigue insomnia decreased appetite, weight loss social withdrawal suicidal thoughts In 1996 the BDI underwent revision as (BDI-II) enhancing its content validity with the aim of focusing on depression symptoms criteria presented by Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV. Numerous researches concentrating on the psychometric assessment of depression used BDI.,,
The technique used for sampling was convenient.
A sample size of 300 was calculated by the formula:
The sample size was calculated based on the proportion of depression among medical students reported by a previous study., It was estimated using a proportion of depression as 40% at confidence level 95% and bound of error 3%.
Data collection procedure
The administration of each medical school was properly approached, and later each student was individually approached as well. After obtaining their time and identifying their space, the data were collected.
The inclusion criteria were: Age of the participant (20–25 years).
The students who were already diagnosed and treated for any psychological disorder or any comorbid were excluded from the study. All those who did not give their consent were also excluded from the study.
The dependent variable is depression and the independent variable were age, gender, religion, marital status, father's occupation, ethnicity, and the addiction history of the participants.
Data were entered into EpiData version 3 and analyzed in SPSS version 20. Frequencies, mean, deviation and standard deviation were calculated for quantitative variables, and proportions were calculated in qualitative variables. The association between dependent and independent variables was determined through regression analysis. In regression analysis, univariate and multivariate analysis to see the association between dependent and independent variables.
Informed written consent was obtained before study from the parent and target medical institutes. The participants were assured confidentiality and given the option to participate in the study without any further questions and implications. Institutional ethical clearance was obtained.
There was no conflict of interest among stakeholders.
| Results|| |
Of 300 medical students, 27.3% were males, and 72.7% were female students. Mean age of students was 23 years and SD was ±2 years, 5.7% were married, 11% had past depression history, and 5.3% had family history of depression [Table 1].
In public sector medical school, 9.7% of students were found to suffer from depression. Depression was more common in female students (9.6%) than males (7.3%). It was significantly higher in the age group 20–23 years (9.3%) than the age group 24–25 years (5.3%). Depression was more common in Urdu speaking (9.7%) and married students (41.2%). It was higher in people with past depression history (42.4%), family history of depression (22.2%), and addiction history (31.2%) [Table 2].
|Table 2: Comparison of sociodemographic characteristics between normal and depressed study participants|
Click here to view
In univariate analysis, married students were 9 times more likely to suffer from depression (odds ratio [OR]: 9.205, confidence interval [CI]: 3.165–26.770), students with a past depression history were 14 times more likely to suffer from depression (OR: 14.397, CI: 5.928–34.961), students with family history were 3.6 times more likely to suffer from depression (OR: 3.684, CI: 1.477–9.189), students with an addiction history were 5 times more likely to suffer from depression (OR: 5.413, CI: 1.729–16.979) and students whose father had been working as a businessman were significantly 2.9 times more likely to suffer from depression (OR: 2.92, CI: 1.024–5.127) [Table 3].
|Table 3: Association between sociodemographic characteristics of study participants and depression (univariate analysis)|
Click here to view
On multivariate analysis, students with a past depression history of at least 6 months were significantly 8.3 times more likely to suffer from depression (OR: 8.309, CI: 2.971–23.244), whereas no significant association of other sociodemographic characteristics with depression was observed in multivariate analysis [Table 4].
|Table 4: Association between sociodemographic characteristics of study participants and depression (multivariate analysis)|
Click here to view
In public sector medical school, 9.7% were found to suffer from depression. In private sector medical school, 8.3% were found to suffer from depression [Figure 1].
|Figure 1: Comparison of depression between students of public and private sector medical schools|
Click here to view
In public sector medical school, 20% of students aged 24–25, 36% with a past depression history, 33% with an addiction history and 11% with a sound financial background were found to be depressed [Figure 2].
|Figure 2: Risk factors associated with depression in public medical schools|
Click here to view
In private sector medical school, 11% of students aged 20–23, 51% with a past depression history, 21% with an addiction history and 17% with a sound financial background were found to be depressed [Figure 3].
|Figure 3: Risk factors associated with depression in private medical schools|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
In this research study, it was found that the public sector medical school students are comparatively more depressed than the students of private sector medical schools. The major causes of depression in the research are mostly related to the female gender, younger age group, financial constraints, married individuals, past depression history, family history of depression and family problems, and an addiction history. These causes of depression are consistent with the findings of our research study as well.
We found out that depression is more common in public (government) based medical institutions (OR: 1.185, CI: 0.537–2.614) as compared to private medical institutions through our research study. In previous studies, the depression among the students of public medical students has been estimated to be 15.2% in the USA, 24% in the UK, 29.1% in India, and 43.8% in Pakistan, which is consistent with the findings of this study. This is related to a number of factors which may include age, gender, marital status, and a past depression history.
Young adults are more likely to be affected as compared to older adults. The age group of 20–23 years (OR: 0.545, CI: 0.070–4.248) is more affected than the age group of 24–25-year-old students according to this research study. Another study stated poor quality work by medical students aged 20–22 years (OR: 0.81, CI: 0.53–1.23). The findings of this research study are consistent with it. Different reasons are associated with it such as school pressure, peer pressure, family problems, sense of loss, self-doubt, high expectations, etc.
Females of all age groups are more commonly affected as compared to males., We found in our study that females (OR: 0.741, CI: 0.288–1.906) are a more depressed group than the males. This was also stated in certain previous studies (OR: 2.05, CI: 1.42–2.95), the findings of which are contradicted with that of this study. This could be because the majority of the study participants in our study belonged to the female gender and so it is not comparable to the previous studies. It is clear that females, particularly those belonging to the middle and lower classes of our society, are faced with much higher social, cultural, and economic pressures. This is further attenuated by the lack of proper facilities (social, medical/maternal).
In addition to the above aspect, it is commonly seen that married women are more depressed. They suffer a greater amount of depression as compared to the unmarried individuals. In our research study, married students (OR: 9.205, CI: 3.165–26.770) were more affected than the unmarried ones. These findings are consistent with the findings of previous studies (OR: 2.52). There are various factors behind this such as financial stress, parenthood, exhaustion, challenging in-laws, miscommunication, work stress, and others.
In terms of the type of life events, it is seen that depressed patients experience significantly higher proportion of life events related to the death of a family member, personal health related events, bereavement, interpersonal, and social events. Students with depression history (OR: 14.397, CI: 5.928–34.961), and family history (OR: 3.684, CI: 1.477–9.189) were found to be more depressed than the students without such history in our research study. This finding is also consistent with the previous studies (past depression history OR: 1.8–2.3; 95% CIs: 1.05–4.02) and (family history OR: 4.4).
Other factors such as smoking, drug abuse, and primary metabolic disorder are likely to be present in almost every society. Participants with an addiction history (OR: 5.413, CI: 1.729–16.979) were more depressed than those without such history according to our study. This has also been stated in previous studies (OR = 1.454) based on suicide and drug abuse, consistent with the findings of this study. These are mostly associated with the socioeconomic factors of an individual and therefore mainly prevail in the ones with the poor economic background.
Subjects with poor economic background and poor nutritional status are more depressed than their financially sound counterparts. Financially, sound (OR: 2.152, CI: 0.863–5.368) were found to be more depressed than the salary person in our study. This aspect was also discussed by a number of researchers based on their study of slums and poor (OR [low and high groups, respectively], 5.4–6.9). The findings of this study contradict with that of the previous studies. This could be because of the increasing communication gap among the family members, spending a little time with them due to busy life styles and the family issues arising in the result.
The solution to above-mentioned factors is based on individual's own capability of dealing with it. Overcoming the reason behind depression mainly depends on the person's social and physical environment and how one copes with it. One of the necessities to overcome depression is the financial support. The stakeholders should get involved to make it possible. There is also a need for large-scale studies to eradicate depression as much as possible from the society. Avoiding alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs is another way to overcome depression on an individual level.
The strength of this study is that in contrast to most of the previous studies, we compared the depression rate among the students of the public and private sector medical schools. This study also determines the associated factors of depression in the study participants which includes their age, gender, marital status, depression and family history. At the same times, this study is limited because of the time constraint, lack of resources, and the small sample size. Is also does not determine the causal factors which are associated with depression.
| Conclusion|| |
The study identified that depression is more common in public colleges among married females in their early twenties of low socioeconomic status and with depression history. There is an urgent need to combat depression, the integrated action is required by different stakeholders.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Khan MS, Mahmood S, Badshah A, Ali SU, Jamal Y. Prevalence of depression, anxiety and their associated factors among medical students in Karachi, Pakistan. J Pak Med Assoc 2006;56:583-6.
Frank E, Karp JF, Rush AJ. Efficacy of treatments for major depression. Psychopharmacol Bull 1993;29:457-75.
Saipanish R. Stress among medical students in a Thai medical school. Med Teach 2003;25:502-6.
Sherina MS, Rampal L, Kaneson N. Psychological stress among undergraduate medical students. Med J Malaysia 2004;59:207-11.
Firth-Cozens J. Stress in medical undergraduates and house officers. Br J Hosp Med 1989;41:161-4.
Yusoff M, Rahim AA, Yaacob M. P02-110-depression among final year medical students in universiti sains malaysia (USM): Associated, risk and determinant factors. Eur Psychiatry 2011;26:706.
Dahlin ME, Runeson B. Burnout and psychiatric morbidity among medical students entering clinical training: A three year prospective questionnaire and interview-based study. BMC Med Educ 2007;7:6.
Sidana S, Kishore J, Ghosh V, Gulati D, Jiloha R, Anand T. Prevalence of depression in students of a medical college in New Delhi: A cross-sectional study. Australas Med J 2012;5:247-50.
Jadoon NA, Yaqoob R, Raza A, Shehzad MA, Zeshan SC. Anxiety and depression among medical students: A cross-sectional study. J Pak Med Assoc 2010;60:699-702.
Singh A, Lal A, Singh S. Prevalence of depression among medical students of a private medical college in India. Online J Health Allied Sci 2011;9:1-5.
Inam SN, Saqib A, Alam E. Prevalence of anxiety and depression among medical students of private university. J Pak Med Assoc 2003;53:44-7.
Bayram N, Bilgel N. The prevalence and socio-demographic correlations of depression, anxiety and stress among a group of university students. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2008;43:667-72.
Guthrie E, Black D, Bagalkote H, Shaw C, Campbell M, Creed F. Psychological stress and burnout in medical students: A five-year prospective longitudinal study. J R Soc Med 1998;91:237-43.
Rosal MC, Ockene IS, Ockene JK, Barrett SV, Ma Y, Hebert JR. A longitudinal study of students' depression at one medical school. Acad Med 1997;72:542-6.
Stewart SM, Betson C, Marshall I, Wong CM, Lee PW, Lam TH. Stress and vulnerability in medical students. Med Educ 1995;29:119-27.
Guthrie EA, Black D, Shaw CM, Hamilton J, Creed FH, Tomenson B. Embarking upon a medical career: Psychological morbidity in first year medical students. Med Educ 1995;29:337-41.
Stewart SM, Betson C, Lam TH, Marshall IB, Lee PW, Wong CM. Predicting stress in first year medical students: A longitudinal study. Med Educ 1997;31:163-8.
Brunt A, Rhee Y, Zhong L. Differences in dietary patterns among college students according to body mass index. J Am Coll Health 2008;56:629-34.
Sharp LK, Lipsky MS. Screening for depression across the lifespan: A review of measures for use in primary care settings. Am Fam Physician 2002;66:1001-8.
Teri L. The use of the beck depression inventory with adolescents. J Abnorm Child Psychol 1982;10:277-84.
Beck AT, Steer RA, Carbin MG. Psychometric properties of the beck depression inventory: Twenty-five years of evaluation. Clin Psychol Rev 1988;8:77-100.
Naveen S, Swapna M, Jayanthkumar K. Stress, anxiety and depression among students of selected medical and engineering colleges, Bangalore – A comparative study. Int J Public Ment Health Neurosci 2015;2:14-8.
Tjia J, Givens JL, Shea JA. Factors associated with undertreatment of medical student depression. J Am Coll Health 2005;53:219-24.
Ross CE, Mirowsky J. Components of depressed mood in married men and women. The center for epidemiologic studies' depression scale. Am J Epidemiol 1984;119:997-1004.
Khanlou N, Pilkington FB. Women's Mental Health. Your University, USA: Springer; 2015.
Karney BR, Bradbury TN. The longitudinal course of marital quality and stability: A review of theory, method, and research. Psychol Bull 1995;118:3-34.
Bromberger JT, Kravitz HM, Wei HL, Brown C, Youk AO, Cordal A, et al.
History of depression and women's current health and functioning during midlife. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2005;27:200-8.
Muzina DJ, Kemp DE, McIntyre RS. Differentiating bipolar disorders from major depressive disorders: Treatment implications. Ann Clin Psychiatry 2007;19:305-12.
Huntley A. The Relationship Between Drug Use and Depressive Symptoms among High School Students; 2015.
Syme SL, Berkman LF. Social class, susceptibility and sickness. Am J Epidemiol 1976;104:1-8.
Aslund C, Leppert J, Starrin B, Nilsson KW. Subjective social status and shaming experiences in relation to adolescent depression. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2009;163:55-60.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]